SIPPs and ISAs: Understanding your options

Learn how Self-Invested Personal Pensions (SIPPs) and stocks and shares ISAs work and which may be right for you.

Key points:

  • Self-Invested Personal Pensions (SIPPs) are built for long‑term retirement saving, offering tax relief on what you pay in but locking your money away until later life.
  • Using both a SIPP and a stocks and shares ISA can balance flexibility and tax efficiency, helping you build accessible savings while also planning for retirement.

Investment values can go down as well as up, and you might get back less than what you put in.

Tax relief is not specific to Self-Invested Personal Pensions (SIPPs) and can apply to other types of pensions, including workplace and personal pensions, subject to HMRC rules and individual circumstances.

Self-invested personal pensions (SIPPs) and stocks and shares ISAs are two ways to potentially grow your money through investing, but they work differently. In this article, although there are different types of ISAs, we’ll specifically be looking at stocks and shares ISAs. Understanding how each is taxed and their flexibilities can help you choose the option that fits your goals and financial circumstances best. 

Just remember, whether you choose a SIPP or an ISA, the value of investments can go down as well as up, so you could get back less than you put in.

What are the differences between a SIPP and ISA?

Both a SIPP and an ISA allow you to invest in a wide range of assets, but they do work differently. A SIPP is designed specifically for long-term retirement planning, offers tax relief on contributions, and locks your money away until you’re 55 (rising to 57 on 6 April 2028). An ISA is a flexible tax-efficient savings and investment account that has no age-related access restrictions. 

A SIPP could suit people who want a dedicated retirement pot with a wider investment choice and who want to benefit from tax relief.

ISAs can be ideal for medium to long term goals where you want tax free income and growth as well as the freedom to withdraw money as and when you need it.

SIPP allowance and how it works

The current SIPP annual allowance is £60,000. Footnote [1] Contributions in excess of the annual allowance will incur an income tax charge. Additionally, tax relief on your personal contributions is restricted to 100% of your UK earnings. These limits apply across all your pensions not per pension.

You also have the option to carry over some of your unused annual allowance, known as carry forward. Footnote [1] It lets you use any unused annual allowance from the previous three tax years, but there are a few rules you need to follow. To use carry forward, you need to:

  • have used your current year's annual allowance in full.
  • have been a member of a UK pension scheme in any of the three years you want to use your carry forward from.

There’s also a tapered allowance, which applies if you earn over £260,000 a year. The £60,000 annual allowance gets tapered down for higher earners by £1 for every £2 you earn over £260,000, down to a minimum of £10,000.Footnote [2]

If you’ve flexibly accessed any taxable benefits from a defined contribution pension, it can affect how much you’re allowed to pay into your pension going forward. Flexible access includes:

  • taking income or a short‑term annuity from a flexi‑access drawdown fund
  • taking cash directly from your pension as an uncrystallised funds pension lump sum (UFPLS)

When you do this, it will trigger the Money Purchase Annual Allowance (MPAA), reducing the amount you can pay into defined contribution pensions, like a SIPP, each year to £10,000 while still receiving tax relief.Footnote [3]

ISA allowance and what you can save each year

ISAs also come with an annual allowance, which at the moment sits at £20,000. Footnote [4] This allowance, like the pension annual allowance, is across all of your ISAs. But unlike pensions, your annual allowance can’t be carried forward, so once it’s gone, it’s gone.

How do SIPPs and ISAs compare on tax advantages?

SIPPs and ISAs both offer great tax benefits, but they support your finances in different ways. SIPPs are designed to encourage long-term retirement saving by giving you tax relief on the money you put in, while an ISA focuses on giving you tax-free income and growth and withdrawals with maximum flexibility. However, the trade-off is that each comes with certain limitations that are worth considering.

What are the SIPP tax benefits?

With a SIPP, your investment growth is free from income tax and capital gains tax. You also get tax relief on your contributions, as the government adds 20%, making your £80 contribution, £100. Higher and additional-rate taxpayers can claim back extra relief through their self-assessment tax return. When it comes to taking money out, you’re usually able to withdraw 25% of your pot tax-free, with the rest added to your other income and taxed at your normal rate.

The flip side is that access to your money is restricted. You usually can’t withdraw funds until at least age 55 (57 from 2028), and when you do, at least 75% of your withdrawals are taxed as income. There are also limits on how much you can contribute each year and still receive tax relief, which may affect higher earners or those making large contributions.

What are the stocks and shares ISA tax benefits?

A stocks and shares ISA gives the gift of all of your investment income and growth and withdrawals being completely tax-free. You won’t have to pay capital gains tax on any profits, or income tax on the money you take out or any income earned, no matter how much your investments have grown.

However, ISAs don’t offer upfront tax relief on contributions, unlike pensions. This means you’re investing from your already-taxed income. There’s also an annual contribution limit, and while access is flexible, this can make it easier to dip into your investments and potentially disrupt long-term growth.

When might a SIPP or ISA be suitable?

It's natural to wonder whether a SIPP or a stocks and shares ISA is the better choice. The truth is that neither is better than the other. Both can be useful ways to save and invest, but they have different features and benefits. Which one is right for you will depend on your personal circumstances, financial goals and when you're likely to need access to your money.

A SIPP is built for long‑term retirement saving. Your money is locked away until at least age 55 (57 from 2028), which makes it a dedicated pot for later life. The structure encourages you to think about long‑term goals and gives you tax advantages designed specifically for retirement planning. However, that same lack of access can be a drawback if your circumstances change or you need funds earlier than expected.

A stocks and shares ISA, on the other hand, is far more flexible. You can withdraw money whenever you need to, making it suitable for medium‑term goals, like buying a car or funding a house deposit, as well as longer‑term investing if you want tax‑free income and growth without the commitment of a pension. Different types of ISAs can also support a range of needs, from short‑term saving to building wealth over many years.

Before choosing either account, it’s worth making sure you have enough cash set aside for unexpected events. Investments take time to grow and can fall in value, so it’s helpful to have a financial buffer in place.

If you're still stumped over whether a SIPP or an ISA is right for you, then you should speak to your financial adviser. If you don’t have an adviser, MoneyHelper provides up-to-date online resources to help you find regulated advisers, or call 0800 011 3797. Advisers may charge for their advice, but there are usually a number of ways to pay. We also offer financial advice if you have £300,000 or more in pension and investment savings.

When to consider using both a SIPP and ISA

SIPPs and ISAs can work well together, depending on your goals. In fact, using both can be an effective way to balance long-term retirement planning with shorter-term flexibility.

You might choose to split your savings by timeframe. Money you may want to access before your 50s for things like a house deposit, or bigger life events, can sit in an ISA, growing tax-free but always within reach. Any savings you’re confident you won’t need until retirement can go into a SIPP, where the combination of tax relief and long‑term investing can help build a larger pot over time.

Taking a dual approach can mean you don’t have to choose between flexibility and long-term tax advantages. Instead, you use each account for what its best at.

Plan your future with Aviva

An Aviva SIPP or stocks and shares ISA can help you invest towards your financial goals with a range of investment options. Investment values can rise and fall.